Isra And Miraj Controversy Over Its Historicity The Term

It is believed to have been followed by the Miraj, his ascension to heaven. It is considered to have happened just over a year before the Hijra, on the 27th of Rajab ; the date is celebrated as a holiday in some parts of the Muslim world.

The siras go into great detail about this; however, a summary version might run:

As he was resting in the Kaaba, Gabriel came to him, and brought him the winged steed Buraq, who carried him to the Temple MountThe Temple Mount or Noble Sanctuary ( Hebrew language: Har HaBayit Arabic language: Al-Haram As-Sharif , is a hotly contested religious site in the old city of Jerusalem. It was the site of the first and second Jewish Temple in Jerusalem and according to in Jerusalem, where he alighted, tethered Buraq, and led other prophetIn numerous religions, including Abrahamic religions, Jah religions, Sikhism, and many forms of Paganism, a prophet is an intermediary with a deity, particularly someone who speaks for the deity or interprets the deity's will or mind. A prophet usually ops in prayer. He then got back on Buraq, and was taken to the heavens, where he toured heavenThe heavens are the sky, the celestial sphere, or outer space. Indeed, sky is the original meaning of the word Heaven''. Heaven is an afterlife concept found in many world religions or spiritual philosophies. Those who believe in heaven generally hold tha and hellHell is, according to many religious beliefs about the afterlife, a place of torment, of great weeping and gnashing of teeth. The English word 'hell' comes from the Norse Hel', which originally referred to the goddess of the Norse underworld. In most reli (described in some detail), and spoke with the earlier prophets, and with Allahcalligraphic Arabic Allah (pronounced: Allaah), is traditionally used by Muslims as the Arabic name of God. The word Allah is not specific to Islam; Arab Christians and Jews, and the Catholic Maltese, also use it to refer to the monotheist deity; for exam. Allahcalligraphic Arabic Allah (pronounced: Allaah), is traditionally used by Muslims as the Arabic name of God. The word Allah is not specific to Islam; Arab Christians and Jews, and the Catholic Maltese, also use it to refer to the monotheist deity; for exam told him to enjoin the Muslims to pray fifty times a day; however, Moses told Muhammad that they would never do it, and urged Muhammad to go back several times and ask for a reduction, until finally it was reduced to five times a day.

Afterwards, the unbelieving Meccans regarded this as absurd, and some went to Abu Bakr and told him "Look at what your companion is saying. He says he went to Jerusalem and came back in one night." Abu Bakr told them, "If he said that, then he is truthful. I believe him concerning the news of the heavens--that an angel descends to him from the heavens. How could I not believe he went to Jerusalem and came back in a short period of time--when these are on earth?" It was for this that Abu Bakr is said to have received his nickname "as-Siddiq", the believer.

1 Controversy over its historicity

Obviously, many non-Muslims regard the incident as implausible a priori. However, while most scholars accept that Muhammad claimed to have made this trip, a few dispute this as well.

John Wansbrough (a leading exponent of extreme scepticism regarding early Islamic sources, best known for his idea that the Qur'an was compiled only 200 years after Muhammad's death), for instance, argues that the entire story of the Isra and Miraj constitutes later Islamic scriptural exegesis designed to explain away the vagueness of ayah 17:1 (a literary phenomenon he claims was common in early Islamic and Jewish theology.) He holds that this verse probably does not even refer to Muhammad, and that no evidence links it to Jerusalem: "Far from providing unambiguous witness to the Arabian prophet, this particular scriptural image (israa' bi-abdeehee laylan) is employed, in but slightly varying forms, only to describe Moses' departure from Egypt" (Wansbrough, Quranic Studies).

2 The term "Masjid al-Aqsa" in the Quran

The "farthest Mosque" (al-masjid al-Aqṣa) in verse (17:1) of the Qur'an is traditionally interpreted by Muslims as referring to the site at the Noble Sanctuary ( Temple Mount) in Jerusalem on which the mosque of that name now stands. This interpretation is already given by the earliest biographer of Muhammad - Ibn Ishaq - and is confirmed by numerous Hadith. The term used for mosque, "masjid", literally means "place of prostration", and includes monotheistic places of worship such as Solomon's Temple, which in verse 17:7 (in the same sura) is described as a masjid.

Many Western historians regard this as the originally intended interpretation, for instance Heribert Busse and Neal Robinson (see references.) However, some disagree, arguing that at the time this verse of the Quran was recited (around the year 621, unless you believe Wansbrough) many Muslims understood the phrase "furthest mosque" as a poetic phrase for a mosque already known to them, a mosque in Heaven, or as a metaphor. For the following reasons, they find it unlikely that this verse referred to a location in Palestine:

There were already two places that Muslim tradition of that time period called "the furthest mosque"; one was the mosque in Medina (Arthur Jeffrey, The Suppressed Quran Commentary of Muhammad Abu Zaid, Der Islam, 20 (1932): 306) and the other was the mosque in the town of Jirana, which Muhammed is said to have visited in 630, although Solomon's Temple is of course further than either. (Alfred Guillaume, Where Was Al-Masjid Al-Aqsa? Al-Andalus, (18) 1953: 323-36)
When Muslims finally did conquer and occupy Jerusalem, they are not known to have identified the Temple Mount with "the furthest Mosque" until 715.

In 715 the Umayyads built a new mosque on the Temple Mount; they named this Mosque al-masjid al-aqsa, the Al-Aqsa Mosque or "furthest mosque". A. L. Tibawi, a Palestinian historian, argues that this action "gave reality to the figurative name used in the Koran." (A. L. Tibawi, Jerusalem: Its Place in Islam and Arab History, Beirut: Institute for Palestine Studies, 1969, p. 9.)

The evidence is insufficient to confirm whether a specific meaning had been attached to this verse before the Muslim conquest and occupation of Jerusalem. However, it is known that by 25 years after the conquest the account of the Isra and Miraj was generally believed.

3 External references

"Night Journey"
The Miracle of al-Isra and al-Miraj
Egyptian Ministry of Culture Publication: The Prophet Muhammad's 'Night Journey' was Not to Jerusalem but to Medina
A. Bevan, Mohammed's Ascension to Heaven, in "Studien zu Semitischen Philologie und Religionsgeschichte Julius Wellhausen," (Topelman, 1914,pp. 53-54.)
B. Schreike, "Die Himmelreise Muhammeds," Der Islam 6 (1915-16): 1-30
J. Horovitz, "Muhammeds Himmelfahrt," Der Islam 9 (1919): 159-83
Heribert Busse, "Jerusalem in the Story of Muhammad's Night Journey and Ascension," Jerusalem Studies in Arabic and Islam 14 (1991): 1-40.
Heribert Busse and Georg Kretschmar, Jerusalemer Heiligstumstraditionen (Wiesbaden: Otto Harrassowitz, 1987)
Heribert Busse, "The Destruction Of The Temple And Its Reconstruction In The Light Of Muslim Exegesis Of Sûra 17:2-8", Jerusalem Studies In Arabic And Islam, 1996, Vol. 20, p. 1.
N. Robinson, Discovering The Qur'ân: A Contemporary Approach To A Veiled Text, 1996, SCM Press Ltd.: London, p. 192.

<Hide>

Home > Isra and Miraj

1 Controversy over its historicity

2 The term "Masjid al-Aqsa" in the Quran

3 External references

Topics: Isra And Miraj, Controversy Over Its Historicity, The Term...