2 History

Since the creation of New France, there has not been a time when Canada was not a monarchy. In fact, Canada is one of the oldest continuing monarchies in the world, first under the kings of France in the 16th, 17th, and 18th centuries and then under the British crown in the 18th and 19th centuries. Following ConfederationCanadian Confederation or the Confederation of Canada was the process that ultimately brought together a union among the provinces, colonies and territories of British North America to form a Dominion of the British Empire, which today is a federal nation, the "Canadianization" of the crown began.

The Royal and Parliamentary Titles ActThe Royal and Parliamentary Titles Act, 1927 was a significant landmark in the constitutional history of the United Kingdom and British Empire. The act had two concequences. The first was to change the full name of the United Kingdom to The United Kingdom, 1927 replaced the concept of a singular crown throughout the British Empire with multiple crowns with each dominion as a separate kingdom, all worn by the common monarch. The Statute of Westminster 1931The Statute of Westminster 1931 was the enactment of the United Kingdom Parliament ( December 11, 1931) which established the legislative sovereignty of the self-governing Dominions of the British Empire. There exist also the unrelated Statutes of Westmin granted the dominions of the Commonwealth autonomy from the British parliament and equality with the United Kingdom. However, when a new Royal Titles Act was passed at the beginning of Queen Elizabeth's reign, it gave primacy to the monarch's status as Queen of the United Kingdom. Canada's constitution was patriated under Prime Minister Trudeau in 1982, becoming a Canadian law rather than an act of the British parliament which required amendment in both jurisdictions. See Canada Act 1982.

The Constitution Act of 1982 also entrenched the monarchy in Canada, though some have disputed this. Any change to the position of the monarch or the monarch's representatives in Canada now requires the consent of the Senate, the House of Commons, and the legislative assemblies of all the provinces.

The Throne of Canada

Throne Chairs for the Queen of Canada, and the Duke of Edinburgh and the Governor General, in the Canadian Senate, Ottawa. (The front chair is used by the Speaker of the Senate).

Today, virtually all of the Queen's Canadian duties are performed by her representatives in Canada, the Governor General and the lieutenant governors of the provinces, though occasionally the Queen's authority is appealed to by Canada's partisan political leaders. In 1990, Prime Minister Brian Mulroney appealed to the Queen (under Section 26 of The Constitution Act, 1867) to temporarily add eight seats to the Senate (a right reserved for the Queen). Senators are appointed until the age of 75 in Canada. Mulroney made this move to secure passage of the controversial Goods and Services Tax, which faced widespread opposition in Canada and would not have passed without the votes of the newly appointed senators.

This was an occasion on which the Queen played a significant role in Canadian government, though as the monarch's advisors made clear, she felt bound follow the advice of the prime minister, who was answerable to cabinet, parliament, and the Canadian electorate. They argued that to overrule prime ministerial advice would have involved the Queen directly in controversy; by automatically accepting advice she placed the responsibility on the person giving the advice.

It is also possible that if the Governor General decides to go against the Prime Minister's or the government's advice, the Prime Minister could appeal directly to the Queen or even recommend that the Queen to dismiss the Governor General.

3 Republicanism debate

In contrast to Australian republicanism, there is not widespread support for a republic, partly because few Canadians may understand the present monarchical system of government. However, throughout the late 20th century there has been increased discussion, mostly academic, of the need for a "Canadian Monarchy." Some small republican groups, such as Citizens for a Canadian Republic, have formed and some politicians, such as former Deputy Prime Minister John Manley, have expressed interest in ending the monarchy.

The monarchist side, by contrast tends to be considerably better organized and enjoys more mainstream attention. The Monarchist League of Canada currently exists as a strong lobby group advocating and promoting the monarchy in Canada.

Public opinion polls have clearly shown Canadians' mixed feelings towards the monarchy. However, it is clear that the prevailing attitude is one of indifference.

Quebec, however, is one province that overwhelmingly supports a republic. This became pronounced in the 1960s due to the growing Quebec separatist movement. A key moment was the Queen's visit to Quebec City in 1964 when she was greeted by anti-monarchist demonstrations and the route of her procession was lined with Quebecers showing their backs to the monarch. On Samedi de la matraque (truncheon Saturday) police violently dispersed anti-monarchist demonstrators and arrested 36. The Queen did not visit Quebec City again until 1987.

Since the mid-20th century there has been a downplaying of the role of the Crown in Canada. During the centennial year of Canadian confederation, in 1967, some Canadian opinion leaders, including the editorial board of the Toronto Star began to advocate the creation of a republic as a mark of the country's independence. God Save the Queen was replaced as Canada's national anthem and is now rarely heard in comparison with O Canada. From the early 1970s, all references to the monarch and the monarchy were slowly removed from the public eye (e.g., the Queen's portrait began to be taken down in public buildings and schools, and the Royal Mail was changed to Canada Post). In recent years there have been some attempts at removing references of the Queen from the Oath of Allegiance. Many point out that this process of downplaying the monarchy has led to widespread misunderstandings about the institution and how Canada is governed.

3.1 Pro and Con

Monarchists argue that having a monarchy, with a Queen of Canada and a governor-general, is one of the key identity differences between the United States and Canada and thus an important way to maintain the country's independence from its southern neighbour, an ongoing theme in Canadian culture and politics. They point to the fact that a republican president in Canada might be seen just another president on the American continent where the most prominent president is the President of the United States.

It is also noted that whereas Canada currently has a female head of state and a female governor-general and has had a female prime minister, no woman has ever been president or vice-president in the United States. They also argue that a republican head of state would cost more, not less, than the current monarchy, due to additional costs involved in updating the governor-general's residences to full head of state presidential palace level, the costs of state visits, political advisors, increased ceremonial functions, etc - functions that in many cases do not exist for a governor-general, given that they are not a full head of state, but which would be required for a Canadian president.

Queen Elizabeth II wearing the Order of Canada

Opponents of the monarchy claim that its abolition would be a blow for democracy and remove an unnecessary expense for the Canadian taxpayer. Many Canadian republicans also say it would remove Canada's last political connection to her colonial past, and thus improve her image as a sovereign nation. At the same time, monarchists argue that Canadians would spend more money on a presidential head of state. Monarchists also argue that a nation's history and past are the building blocks of a national identity.

Prominent critics of the monarchy such as Citizens for a Canadian Republic point out that the Act of Settlement explicitly excludes Roman Catholics from the throne and the Queen is Supreme Governor of the Church of England, requiring her to be an Anglican. This, they argue, discriminates against non-Anglicans, including Catholics who are the largest faith group in Canada. Former Toronto city councillor Tony O'Donohue launched a court action in 2002 arguing that the Act of Settlement violates the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms in that it discriminates against Catholics. His case was dismissed by the court, which found that the Act of Settlement is part of the Canadian constitution and thus the Charter of Rights does not have supremacy over it.

Monarchists claim that since unanimity by all Canadian provinces is required to replace the monarchy, a republic will never be attained. To counter this argument, Citizens for a Canadian Republic in March 2004 proposed measures to avoid constitutional deadlock by advocating a parliamentary reform of the office of the governor general, an office generally expected to be transformed into a presidency should the monarchy end. The group claims their proposal will address divisive aspects such as the duties and selection process of the new head of state without constitutional amendment, leaving the remaining issue of who should occupy the position to be decided in a referendum. On April 2, 2004, the House of Commons Standing Committee on Government Operations and Estimates endorsed this formula, but no government action has been taken.

There is also, in large part because of previous long disputes over constitutional issues and reforms, a reluctance to enter into the extensive constitutional renegotiation that would be required to establish a new political system in Canada. Unlike Australia, where constitutional reform is confined largely to the future of the monarchy, in Canada, there are comparatively more pressing constitutional issues. Consequently, the 2004 election platforms of the main political parties focused far more upon the reform or abolition of the Senate, appointment of Supreme Court judges, and the powers of provincial governments, than on the future of the monarchy.

This issue is not now an important one in Canadian public affairs, and it is widely predicted that there will no real debate on the future of the monarchy in Canada until the death of the present Queen. Even then, the future of the monarchy in Canada could depend on the Queen's successor. While Prince Charles is still unpopular in Canada, his son, Prince William, remains extremely popular, especially among the younger generation of Canadians (polls have noted that popular support for the monarchy amongst 18 to 30 year olds has been rising in recent years). Moreover, after reports that the Governor General of Canada's spending had increased nearly 200% in the last few years, there were calls to end the office of the Governor General, yet at the same time, there were no calls to remove the Queen as head of state.

4 Recent polls on the monarchy in Canada

Support for the monarchy in Canada dropped to record lows in the late 1990s. In the first half of the new century support for the monarchy has risen to include the majority of Canadians. However, the fact that many Canadians continue to not completely understand exactly what a " Head of State" is, or the exact nature of the Queen's current role in Canada can cause some problems in drawing concrete conclusions from poll results.

• A 1997 Pollara poll showed only 18% opposed replacing Queen Elizabeth with a Canadian head of state when she dies. However, many monarchists have pointed out that this poll cannot be deemed accurate as the question is misleading, making it seem the current monarchy is not Canadian. 32% favour scrapping the monarchy, 45% don't care and only 21% support it. In Quebec, 70 per cent favoured the abolition of the monarchy. Arthur Bousfield, vice-chairman of the Monarchist League of Canada, said the survey "probably" shows the lowest support for the monarchy ever recorded in a poll in Canada.

4.1 Jubilee polls

In the year 2002, the year of the Queen's golden jubilee, polls were taken by Canada's three biggest polling firms on Canadian views of the monarchy.

• The 2002 Ekos poll found that support for abolition of the monarchy is declining, yet also highlighted many contradictions in public opinion. 48% agreed and 35% disagree with the statement, "Instead of a British monarch we should have a Canadian citizen as our head of state". Yet at the same time 43% disagreed and 41% agreed to the same question, worded slightly differently- "it's time to abolish the monarchy in Canada." Again, monarchists suggest the confusion may arise from the skewed question which refers to the "British monarch" as Canada's head of state (as the distinct Queen of Canada, sovereign of the Canadian Crown, many argue the monarchy is Canadian).

Only 5% were even aware that the Queen was in fact Canada's head of state, with 69% thinking it was the Prime Minister and 9% believing it was the Governor General. 55% agree that the monarchy keeps Canada distinct from the United States, while 33% disagree.

This survey has often been cited as evidence of the confusion that many Canadians have for the role of the monarchy in Canada.

COMPLETE POLL RESULTS - PDF document

• The 2002 Ipsos-Reid poll found that 79% of Canadians support the monarchy as Canada's form of government and 62% believe that the monarchy helps to define Canada's identity. At the same time, 48% would prefer a republican system of government with an elected head of state and two-thirds (65%) believe the royals are merely celebrities and should not have any formal role in Canada.

The same poll also found that 58% don't think the monarchy is an issue important enough to go through the "fuss of changing something that works".

COMPLETE POLL RESULTS - PDF document

• The 2002 Leger Marketing poll found 50% said "yes" to the statement, "Elizabeth II is currently the Queen of Canada. Do you (yes or no) want Canada to maintain the monarchy?" Only 43% said "no". There was majority support for the monarchy in all areas except Québec.

COMPLETE POLL RESULTS - PDF document

5 See also

• Dominion
• Commonwealth Realm
• Australian Constitutional History describes the parallel history of the monarchy in another former British dominion.
• List of Governors General of Canada

• Lists of Lieutenant Governors of:

Alberta - British Columbia - Manitoba - New Brunswick - Newfoundland and Labrador - Nova Scotia - Ontario - Prince Edward Island - Quebec - Saskatchewan - Northwest Territories

• Lists of Commissioners of:

Northwest Territories - Yukon - Nunavut

6 External links

• The Canadian Monarchy - Official Site
• Canadian Monarchist ONLINE - a Canadian website promoting Canada's constitutional monarchy
• Res Publica : Canada - an international anti-monarchy Web directory
• Canadian Monarchist League
• Citizens for a Canadian Republic
• Monarchy-Free Canada

Canadian politics Canadian history British Empire

<Hide>